The Discovery Gap: Understanding the Financial Resources Available in Divorce
By David Voorhees, CFE, CAMS, Illuminate Risk
Divorce can create an immediate information imbalance when one spouse has
historically managed more of the household finances. The other spouse may know
there are financial questions that need to be answered but may not know where
to begin, which documents matter, or what level of professional assistance is
appropriate.
Fortunately, there are a range of resources available.
Some preliminary financial information can be gathered from records a
spouse already has a legal right to access. Attorneys can use the formal
discovery process to obtain additional information. Targeted financial
assessments can help organize records and identify areas that warrant further
inquiry. When the financial issues are more complex, forensic accountants can
provide specialized services such as asset tracing, income analysis, business
valuation, lifestyle analysis, and expert support.
Not every divorce requires the same level of financial analysis. In some
matters, an initial review may be enough to identify important questions and
determine which additional records should be requested. In others, the
complexity of the assets, businesses, income streams, or transactions may make
early involvement of a forensic accountant particularly valuable.
The objective is to match the appropriate resource and level of expertise
to the financial issues in the case.
Start With What You Can Access
A useful first step is gathering financial information that is already
lawfully available to you. Depending on your circumstances, that may include:
- Joint and Individual Accounts: Statements for checking and
savings accounts, lines of credit, and credit cards where you are listed
as an account holder.
- Income and Benefit Records: Your W-2s, 1099s, pay stubs,
retirement account balances, HSA histories, and deferred compensation
summaries.
- Household Mail: Statements and correspondence
addressed to you individually or jointly with your spouse. Mail addressed
only to your spouse should be left unopened.
- Public Real Estate Records: Deeds, mortgages, and county tax
assessments available through public records.
- Insurance Policies: Homeowners, umbrella, and auto
insurance declarations may provide useful information about insured
property and other assets.
These records may not provide the complete financial picture, but they
can establish a useful starting point and help identify additional questions
for your attorney or financial professional.
A Free Resource Many People Overlook
If you signed a joint tax return, IRS transcripts may provide another
useful source of financial information. They are available at no cost through
your online IRS account.
Different transcripts provide different types of information.
·
Wage and Income Transcript
A Wage and Income Transcript contains information returns filed under
your Social Security number, including W-2s and certain Forms 1099, 1098, and
5498.
Depending on the forms filed, the transcript may provide information
about wages, interest, dividends, brokerage transactions, retirement
distributions, mortgages, IRAs, and HSAs.
·
Tax Return Transcript
A Tax Return Transcript reflects information from the return as filed.
Unlike the Wage and Income Transcript, which reports information
associated with an individual taxpayer, a joint Tax Return Transcript reflects
information reported on the joint return.
It can provide information about income, business activity, capital
gains, retirement distributions, partnership or S corporation income, and other
items appearing on the return.
·
Account Transcript
An Account Transcript provides information about activity associated with
the tax account, including filing status, adjusted gross income, estimated tax
payments, extensions, balances paid, and refunds.
These details can sometimes help identify additional questions. For
example, estimated tax payments may warrant further inquiry into sources of
income, while a refund may prompt a review of where those funds were deposited.
Looking at the Information Together
Tax transcripts can become particularly useful when reviewed alongside
tax returns, bank statements, brokerage records, and other financial documents.
No single document necessarily provides the entire financial picture.
Instead, each record can serve as another piece of the financial history.
Comparing information across multiple sources may identify accounts,
transactions, income sources, or inconsistencies that deserve additional
attention.
For example, differences between information appearing on a joint tax
return and information reported under an individual taxpayer's Social Security
number may help identify additional sources that should be explored.
These observations can then help an attorney determine whether additional
records should be requested through the discovery process.
Stay Within the Appropriate Boundaries
While gathering financial information can be helpful, it is equally
important to obtain it appropriately.
Only access accounts on which you are an authorized account holder and
use your own credentials. Do not access an account held solely in your spouse's
name or use credentials that you are not authorized to use.
Improperly accessing another person's financial information can create
legal and evidentiary issues. When records are not available to you directly,
your attorney can advise you about appropriate discovery procedures for
obtaining them.
The goal is simple: gather what is lawfully available to you and allow
the legal process to obtain what is not.
Missing Information Can Still Be
Useful Information
When a spouse has had limited involvement in the household finances,
incomplete records are common. That does not mean the financial analysis has
reached a dead end.
Identifying what is missing can itself be useful.
For example, if available records show regular transfers to an account
for which statements have not been produced, that may provide counsel with a
specific account or institution to investigate further.
Similarly, documenting a series of transfers to an unfamiliar account or
entity can create a financial trail that warrants additional inquiry.
This is one area where organized financial analysis can be particularly
helpful. Rather than beginning with a conclusion that assets or income have
been concealed, the analysis can focus on the records themselves: what came in,
what went out, where it went, and what documentation remains unavailable.
That fact-based approach can help attorneys develop more targeted
document requests, subpoenas, and deposition questions.
Know When Additional Expertise May
Help
Preliminary financial analysis can provide a valuable starting point, but
some matters require more specialized expertise.
A forensic accountant may become particularly helpful when the case
involves complex asset tracing, multiple businesses or entities, significant
investment activity, complicated compensation arrangements, disputed income,
separate and marital property issues, lifestyle analysis, business valuation,
or the need for expert testimony.
The timing of that involvement will depend on the case.
In some matters, a preliminary assessment can help narrow the issues
before additional professionals are retained. In others, involving a forensic
accountant early can help shape discovery, identify missing records, preserve
relevant financial information, and avoid duplicating work later.
These resources can complement one another. The important question is not
whether one approach is universally better, but what level of analysis is
appropriate for the financial issues presented.
Safety Comes First
Financial control can sometimes exist alongside other forms of domestic
abuse. If obtaining or reviewing financial records could create a safety
concern, personal safety should take priority.
Do not search for documents or retrieve financial information if doing so
could place you at risk. Consider working from a secure device, speaking with
your attorney, and using formal discovery procedures to obtain information
directly from financial institutions when appropriate.
If you are not safe, the National Domestic Violence Hotline is available
at 800-799-7233, or by texting START to 88788.
Finding the Right Starting Point
Understanding marital finances does not always have to begin with the
most extensive level of analysis. For some clients, a targeted or fixed-fee
assessment of records already available can provide a practical starting point.
An initial assessment can help organize the financial picture, map
accounts and transactions, identify potential gaps, and highlight questions
that may require further investigation. The resulting financial summary can
give the client and family law attorney a clearer understanding of what is
known, what may still be missing, and where additional resources may be useful.
From there, the attorney and client can determine the appropriate next
steps. Those may include additional document requests, formal discovery,
subpoenas, further financial analysis, or engagement of a forensic accountant
for more complex issues.
Illuminate Risk offers one such resource: a fixed-fee assessment designed to help
organize available financial information and provide a starting point for
additional analysis when needed.
The different resources available in a divorce do not need to compete
with one another. Attorneys, targeted financial assessments, forensic
accountants, valuation professionals, and other specialists can each serve
different roles depending on the issues and stage of the matter.
Ultimately, a clearer understanding of the financial picture can help
clients and their attorneys ask better questions, identify appropriate next
steps, and make more effective use of the professional resources available to
them.
This article provides general information about financial documents and
analysis and is not legal advice. Family law rules regarding discovery, marital
property, privacy, and access to financial information vary by jurisdiction.
Consult with your attorney regarding the rules applicable to your
circumstances.
Comments
Post a Comment